As aid responses go, Goma was not badly served. At least 14 villages were Mt Nyiragongo volcano destroyed by the lava as it flowed downhill from Goma nearby town the summit of the volcano in lava streams 2m Lake Kivu nearby lake deep and 50m wide Democratic Republic of Congo African Rift Valley12 hrs: It is arguable that losses would be no less than they are in massive food distributions. For this major and crucial need, only cash would do. Who could ever tell that someone had gone round twice, or that a family was represented at three different distribution points? Surprisingly, even the need for shelter was not as bad as feared, as most of the 80, displaced people moved in with relatives for the first few days. Lessons in Post-Disaster Assistance from Goma, unpublished case study,
The fear of giving money is almost pathological among aid agencies, even though, or maybe because, it would be simpler and cheaper to give than any other form of help. As the lava entered the lake it turned it acidic,poisoning the water and the fish. Exactly the same problems of identification and duplication would have occurred. There is abundant evidence from around the globe that post-disaster economies revive quickly if everyone has a little money to spend. Would the misuse of money in Goma have been any worse than the misuse of goods? Perhaps goods should have been given only to women, as at one point UNICEF had decided to do, or only to children, or only through churches. The search for truth:
The search for truth: Yet aid workers persisted in treating people like children who could not be trusted with their pocket money.
Nyiragongo Published by Guset User The humanitarian situation and response in the Nt. Saunders, Housing, Lives and Livelihoods: At least 45 people died and s are http: Complex justifications are developed.
Volcanoes – Revision 3 – KS3 Geography – BBC Bitesize
Eventually, some of this was done. The fear of giving money is almost pathological among aid agencies, even though, or maybe because, it would be simpler reuption cheaper to give than any other form of help. Goma is well supplied with food, which is normally quite cheap; the problem was the money to buy it with.
Lessons in Post-Disaster Assistance from Goma, unpublished case study, This became a problem in itself, as agencies had become used to the convenience of doing distributions inside a compound, and were reluctant to stop supporting people in the schools. Would the misuse of money in Goma have been any worse than the misuse of goods?
Nyiragojgo lorries or stores are needed, and the logistics are certainly simpler.
Cost-recovery in the health sector: Perhaps goods should have been given only to women, as at one point UNICEF had decided to do, or only to children, or only through churches. There was a lot of lava to clear from the airport runway, for instance; there were roads to be reopened. Mental health needs in Palestine.
The international politics of aid in the occupied Palestinian territory. What they needed was not commodities but cash.
GFE Consulting, Marchhttp: Home Explore Case study of a Volcanic eruption: The town is a busy commercial centre, a hive of economic activity and the main point of entry for goods from the outside world for much of eastern Congo.
Many cross the border intonearby Rwanda and become refugees therewith little food, water or clothes. The people of Goma were clearly right: Why humanitarian assistance is not a long-term solution in the OPT. It is arguable that losses would be no less than they are in massive food distributions. Exactly the same problems of identification and duplication would have occurred.
Case study of a Volcanic eruption : Mt. Nyiragongo
Humanitarian response in the occupied Palestinian territory: But perhaps the aid community could be radical and say that people, especially adults, have a right to misuse their cash.
Families were made to line up for hours to collect meticulously counted and packaged items, and the length of the procedure alone led to frustration, and ultimately to temptation and impersonation.
It was no secret that they were going to sell the goods, and that the ensuing flood of cheap aluminium pots or plastic sheets would debase the local market and make things worse for small traders.
The aid response As aid responses go, Goma was not badly served. A significant population did find it difficult and temporary camps grew up in some of the untouched schools and church compounds, which later had to be evacuated as a major effort was made to restart education.